Easy Bourbon Eggnog (2024)

This post may contain affiliate links.

This Bourbon Eggnog recipe is easy to make and even easier to sip! Not too thick or too sweet, this eggnog and bourbon co*cktail will become a staple of your holiday gatherings.

Blender Eggnog for the Easiest Holiday co*cktail

My dad has been whipping up his famous Blender Eggnog every Christmas for as long as I can remember. When I was little, he’d set aside a cup of eggnog without alcohol for me to sip along with the adults.

Now, I’m happy to partake in the spiked version, with all of its boozy, rich, creamy goodness.

Eggnog seems to be one of those love or hate it kinds of drinks, and I hope today I can bring some of you haters into the “love it” camp.

The truth is, I understand the hate. The first time I tried store bought eggnog (which was well into adulthood), I wasn’t a fan. It was way too thick, very sweet, and lacked flavor. It hardly seemed worth the calories.

But this eggnog? This eggnog with warm bourbon and subtle hints of vanilla? This eggnog is worth every.single.calorie.

Let’s make some!

Why This is The Best Eggnog with Bourbon

This blender eggnog is different from other eggnog recipes in a few key ways:

1. It’s not cooked. Yes, that means we’re using raw eggs. No, I don’t worry about getting sick from drinking it (more on that later!).
2. It’s made without heavy cream. Most eggnog recipes call for a blend of cream and milk, but dad’s version (and the version I prefer) is made with just whole milk. It’s still super creamy, but it’s also very smooth, and doesn’t coat your throat the way some eggnogs do. Of course, if you prefer a thicker texture, you can always substitute some of the milk for cream.
3. It’s spiked with bourbon. Eggnog can be made with all different kinds of spirits, including brandy, rum, or whiskey, but I am partial to bourbon. It’s warm, rich, and smooth, and it cuts the sweetness perfectly.

How to Make Blender Eggnog

1. Place the eggs in a blender and, as my dad says, “beat the heck out of them.”
2. Add the sugar and blend again.
3. Add the milk, vanilla extract, and bourbon, and blend a final time. Chill for at least an hour before serving, but preferably overnight. The flavor gets better as it sits!

How to Serve Bourbon Eggnog

If you love frothy eggnog, be sure to give it another spin in the blender before serving.

Otherwise, I find this eggnog is perfect with a dollop of whipped cream on top.

I also love adding some freshly grated nutmeg on top. The scent of it as you take the first sip is heavenly. You can use a microplane grater to grate nutmeg, but I was gifted this nutmeg grinder a few years ago, and it’s a super fun (and fancy) gadget to get out around the holidays.

Is it Safe to Drink Eggnog with Raw Eggs?

Let’s talk about raw eggs for a sec. I realize the idea of an uncooked eggnog might worry some of you. The risk of getting sick from eating raw eggs in the U.S. is very low, but here are some things you can do to lower or completely eliminate any risk.

• Buy the freshest eggs you can find.
• Wash the shells before cracking them.
• Buy pasteurized eggs- Pasteurized eggs are eggs that are heated in order to kill pathogens. While some companies make pasteurized whole eggs, they can be difficult to find. You can easily substitute pasteurized egg product (the blended kind found in a carton), which can be found in almost any grocery store.

The Best Bourbon for Eggnog

We are fans of Bulleit Bourbon, but Maker’s Mark is also a good choice.

We have also enjoyed Watershed Distillery’s Bourbon, a local Columbus distillery that also ships to many states.

How long does eggnog keep?

Eggnog will keep for up to a week in an airtight container in the fridge. I find it actually gets better as it sits!

More Holiday Drinks

Looking for more great beverages to sip on over the holiday season? Try these Cranberry Mimosas for Christmas morning, or this non-alcoholic Christmas Morning Punch.

Need something warm? Cozy up with a Homemade Tea Latte, make your own spiced Chai Tea Concentrate, or try a Copy Cat Starbuck Cinnamon Dolce Latte.