10 Ways to Dress Store-Bought Items Up for a Potluck — And Have No One Be the Wiser (2024)

  • Skills
  • Dish Types

Kelsey Ogletree

Kelsey Ogletree

updated Jul 17, 2020

facebook

pinterest

email

comments

We independently select these products—if you buy from one of our links, we may earn a commission. All prices were accurate at the time of publishing.

The modern potluck has changed quite a lot over the years. For instance, if you get invited to a Friendsgiving this November and are asked to bring something to share, you’re taking part in a potluck. How we eat, how we organize, even where we hold potlucks has changed (they’re not all in church basem*nts anymore!). But one thing hasn’t changed: Figuring out an easy thing to bring can be difficult.

When you want to impress your friends, but have no time to cook, try one of these smart shortcuts for dressing up store-bought items. They look (and taste) like you spent hours in the kitchen — without the, you know, hours spent in the kitchen.

1. Make a charcuterie board.

A charcuterie board is a no-brainer. It’s easy to assemble and you can purchase the ingredients at most any grocery store. (And, hello, who doesn’t love a charcuterie board?) Joshua Hedquist, executive chef at Giulia inside Hotel Emery in Minneapolis, recommends grabbing three kinds of cheeses, two meats (like a cured hard salami and a fresh Italian meat), one crunchy element (such as fresh bread or crostini), and a jam or preserve, then arranging your bounty on a large platter. Get gourmet by adding a fancy mustard or something pickled, like artichokes, mushrooms, or asparagus, all easily found in the canned food aisle. If you’re really in a pinch for time, you can even buy a pre-made charcuterie board and simply transfer the items to your favorite wooden cutting board.

2. Use a rotisserie chicken.

A freshly roasted, delightfully moist (yes, we’re using that word) rotisserie chicken can be the base for many delectable semi-homemade dishes. Juan Zaragoza, chef at Gracie’s in Hotel deLuxe in Portland, Oregon, advises buying one and shredding it. Take the meat as-is along with taco fixings (here’s an easy recipe) and make a taco bar! Or if you have a little more time, throw the meat into a slow cooker with a jar of your favorite salsa and 2 cups of chicken broth. Cook on high for 30 to 45 minutes for an extra-flavorful taco filling.

3. Dress up meatballs.

Trader Joe’s to the rescue: Pick up a bag of frozen, precooked meatballs and toss them in a slow cooker with a bottle of your favorite savory sauce, such as a spicy barbecue or teriyaki. After an hour or two on low, they’re ready to serve with cute little toothpicks — and no one has to know they’re not homemade.

4. Make nachos.

It barely passes as a “recipe,” but if you’re potlucking somewhere with an available microwave or oven, a platter of gooey nachos is sure to be one of the most-loved items. Grab a bag of chips, a container of fresh pico de gallo, a can of drained-and-rinsed black beans, a handful of fresh cilantro, and a bag or two of thick-cut pre-shredded cheese. Assemble the chips, beans, and cheese on a tray and bake for a few minutes, or put on a pretty plate and microwave. Top with cilantro and pico, and serve. Don’t forget the hot sauce.

5. Bring Nutella brownies.

You can find pans of fresh-baked brownies in the bakery section of most supermarkets. Try this secret for a killer potluck dessert from food blogger Adriana Dikih: Transfer the bars to your own dish, then drizzle with Nutella (warm it in the microwave about 20 seconds to get it to drizzling consistency) and sprinkle with chopped nuts. “It takes five minutes,” says Dikih. “The only problem is, people always ask me for the recipe!”

6. Use a sweet shortcut.

No one will know you didn’t mix, chill, roll, cut, and bake that cookie dough into perfect shapes with this hack for dressing up store-bought cookies. Simply buy a container of cookies at the store (even gluten-free will do!), dip half of each cookie in melted chocolate, and decorate with festive sprinkles to make them appear super-special, says Nealy Fischer, cookbook author and founder of The Flexible Chef.

7. Upgrade your dip.

Transfer a container or two of store-bought hummus to a serving bowl, then top with freshly rinsed (and dried) chickpeas from a can. Add sesame seeds, crushed red pepper flakes, and a drizzle of olive oil, says Fischer.

Or, buy a container of artichoke dip, spread it on a festive plate and top with tons of freshly grated Parmesan cheese and a drizzle of truffle oil, recommends Charles Welch, executive chef at Good Fortune in Chicago. Either can be served with crudités (pre-chopped and from the store), pita chips, or fresh bread warmed in the oven. This is an especially great dish to make if the potluck is at your home.

8. Make hot bar casserole.

Eric Lees, executive chef at Michelin-starred Spiaggia in Chicago, has an expert hack for a Thanksgiving favorite: sweet potato casserole. Hit up the hot bar at Whole Foods for mashed sweet potatoes, then top with your favorite marshmallows and use a blowtorch or your broiler to get them all melty and toasted. “No one will ever suspect it’s a store-bought side dish,” says Lees.

9. Gussy up hot cider.

Pour some store-bought cider into the slow cooker to warm, then garnish it with cinnamon sticks and mulling spices, advises the culinary team behind The Spice House. No one will mind how easy it was to make. They won’t even notice — they’ll be too busy enjoying a glass!

10. Make a “fresh” loaf of bread.

Is there anything as intoxicating as the smell of freshly baked bread? You don’t need to worry about rising times or starter: Buy a loaf of frozen dough, bake it according to directions, and bring it to the party right in the warm pan. Cut it into dip-ready chunks and serve alongside a bowl of good olive oil or one of the dips, above.

Filed in:

appetizer

snacks

10 Ways to Dress Store-Bought Items Up for a Potluck — And Have No One Be the Wiser (2024)

FAQs

10 Ways to Dress Store-Bought Items Up for a Potluck — And Have No One Be the Wiser? ›

What to bring to a potluck last minute? Easy, quick snacks that you can make without needing to heat up anything are your best bet for last-minute potluck prep. Dips, guacamole, lettuce wraps, salsa, salad, and no-bake finger foods are all great options.

What's the worst thing to bring to a potluck? ›

These Are The 5 Worst Dishes To Bring To Holiday Potluck Dinners
  • Baked potatoes in aluminum foil.
  • Mayo-based salads.
  • Fish and seafood.
  • Nuts.
  • Leafy green salads.
Dec 8, 2023

What is the easiest thing to bring to a potluck? ›

What to bring to a potluck last minute? Easy, quick snacks that you can make without needing to heat up anything are your best bet for last-minute potluck prep. Dips, guacamole, lettuce wraps, salsa, salad, and no-bake finger foods are all great options.

What store-bought food can I bring to a potluck? ›

Appetizers
  • Sushi. If there's a boat I want to sail away on, it's a sushi boat. ...
  • Cheese and Charcuterie Fixings. Has anyone ever been sad to see a cheese and charcuterie board at a potluck? ...
  • Canned and Jarred Goods. ...
  • Shrimp and co*cktail Sauce. ...
  • Chips and Dip. ...
  • Frozen Apps. ...
  • Fried Chicken. ...
  • Soup.
Sep 16, 2023

What to bring to a potluck last minute? ›

Whether you're short on time or simply looking for convenient yet delightful options, these dishes are sure to be a hit at any potluck gathering.
  • Caprese Skewers. ...
  • Gourmet Cheese Platter. ...
  • Store-Bought Rotisserie Chicken. ...
  • Tortilla Pinwheels. ...
  • Fruit Salad. ...
  • Frozen Meatballs in Sauce. ...
  • Assorted Cookies. ...
  • Fruit Skewers.
Aug 19, 2024

What not to eat at a potluck? ›

Potato salad, egg salad and macaroni salad are commonly considered a foodborne risk. If you think mayonnaise is the issue, you're going to be surprised.

What is a good finger food to bring to a potluck? ›

Easy Finger Food Recipes to Make Ahead
  • Fried Pickles. Treat your guests to fried pickles for fun finger food ideas. ...
  • Fried Mac and Cheese Rolls. ...
  • Deviled Eggs. ...
  • Honey Garlic Meatballs. ...
  • Garlic Breadsticks. ...
  • Salted Soft Pretzels. ...
  • Whipped Ricotta Crostini. ...
  • Vietnamese Spring Rolls.
4 days ago

What potluck food doesn't need refrigeration? ›

Related Articles
  • Ham-And-Swiss Sliders.
  • Slow-Cooker Grape Jelly Meatballs.
  • Roasted Broccolini With Pecans And Lemon.
  • Bacon Jam.
  • Stuffed Mushrooms.
  • We Know What College You Went To Based On Your Tailgate Spread.
  • 35 Big-Batch Breakfast Recipes For Your Tailgate.
  • Smashed Baby Red Potatoes.
Jun 15, 2017

What are the essentials for a potluck? ›

Remember the Essentials - In addition to plates, cutlery, napkins and cups, remember extra serving utensils and potholders for hot dishes. Don't forget plenty of extra dishcloths and paper towels for spills.

Can you go to a potluck without bringing anything? ›

Anything More Than Empty Hands Is Acceptable

These go hand-in-hand since the food is brought and eaten by the guests themselves. It's a fun communal activity that also takes some weight off the poor host. So can you show up to a potluck empty-handed? Heck no.

What's a good potluck theme? ›

Here are 10 themes to try out for your next potluck.
  • Mexican Night. When it comes to group cooking, Mexican-American food has long been the star — it's delicious, filling, and well-loved. ...
  • Movie Night. ...
  • Sichuan Night. ...
  • A Night in Paris. ...
  • Game Night. ...
  • Childhood Favorites. ...
  • Hot Pot. ...
  • Apps Only.
Nov 15, 2019

What can I say instead of potluck? ›

Synonyms of potlucks
  • picnics.
  • barbeques.
  • cookouts.
  • barbecues.
  • banquets.
  • roasts.
  • bakes.
  • clambakes.

What not to bring to a party? ›

And with any dishes you may bring, don't try to upstage the host or their meal, as you may hurt their feelings. Finally, do not bring anything that's messy or with a strong odor, which will cause more work or a distraction to the host or other guests.

Is it rude to bring pizza to a potluck? ›

If the gathering is fairly large, you'll have to bring multiple pizzas. Many, many people bring ready-made food to potlucks. Not everyone likes to cook, and it's a perfectly acceptable practice to provide something you didn't actually make.

What are two problems that can occur with a potluck? ›

Cross-contamination issues, improper cooking temperatures, improper food holding temperatures, poor hygiene practices, and improper cleaning and disinfecting are all conditions that may contribute to unsafe food and potential foodborne illnesses.

Is it bad to bring store bought food to a potluck? ›

In short, it's completely fine to utilize a shortcut when necessary.

Top Articles
Commonly Asked Questions about Paleo Naan
8 Surprising Celery Juice Benefits - Clean Juice
Diario Las Americas Rentas Hialeah
Www.1Tamilmv.cafe
Using GPT for translation: How to get the best outcomes
Watch Mashle 2nd Season Anime Free on Gogoanime
Autobell Car Wash Hickory Reviews
Puretalkusa.com/Amac
Kostenlose Games: Die besten Free to play Spiele 2024 - Update mit einem legendären Shooter
Mylife Cvs Login
New Mexico Craigslist Cars And Trucks - By Owner
Classic Lotto Payout Calculator
065106619
Axe Throwing Milford Nh
Mikayla Campinos Laek: The Rising Star Of Social Media
Beryl forecast to become an 'extremely dangerous' Category 4 hurricane
Busted Newspaper Fauquier County Va
zom 100 mangadex - WebNovel
At&T Outage Today 2022 Map
Reser Funeral Home Obituaries
Olivia Maeday
Craig Woolard Net Worth
Amerisourcebergen Thoughtspot 2023
Poochies Liquor Store
Xpanas Indo
Tottenham Blog Aggregator
Guinness World Record For Longest Imessage
Mobile crane from the Netherlands, used mobile crane for sale from the Netherlands
Vadoc Gtlvisitme App
10 Best Quotes From Venom (2018)
Revelry Room Seattle
Rubmaps H
What Is The Lineup For Nascar Race Today
Brenda Song Wikifeet
Beaver Saddle Ark
24 slang words teens and Gen Zers are using in 2020, and what they really mean
Lichen - 1.17.0 - Gemsbok! Antler Windchimes! Shoji Screens!
A Man Called Otto Showtimes Near Amc Muncie 12
House Of Budz Michigan
Pinellas Fire Active Calls
Verizon Outage Cuyahoga Falls Ohio
Rhode Island High School Sports News & Headlines| Providence Journal
Improving curriculum alignment and achieving learning goals by making the curriculum visible | Semantic Scholar
2013 Honda Odyssey Serpentine Belt Diagram
Oklahoma City Farm & Garden Craigslist
Theater X Orange Heights Florida
Stephen Dilbeck, The First Hicks Baby: 5 Fast Facts You Need to Know
Random Warzone 2 Loadout Generator
The Goshen News Obituary
Chitterlings (Chitlins)
Ippa 番号
Texas 4A Baseball
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Msgr. Refugio Daniel

Last Updated:

Views: 5936

Rating: 4.3 / 5 (54 voted)

Reviews: 85% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Msgr. Refugio Daniel

Birthday: 1999-09-15

Address: 8416 Beatty Center, Derekfort, VA 72092-0500

Phone: +6838967160603

Job: Mining Executive

Hobby: Woodworking, Knitting, Fishing, Coffee roasting, Kayaking, Horseback riding, Kite flying

Introduction: My name is Msgr. Refugio Daniel, I am a fine, precious, encouraging, calm, glamorous, vivacious, friendly person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.